• Sign in
  • |
  • Sign up

Andy Mohr Toyota

8941 E US HIGHWAY 36AVON, IN 46123
1-888-970-90131-888-970-9013
  • Chat for instant answers
  •  Visit our website 
  •  Finance a vehicle with us
  •  Like 
  •  Follow 

Services and Amenities

  • Service Centers
  • Factory Authorized Service Center
  • Body Shop
  • Parts & Accessories
  • Detailing
  • Internet Access
  • Handicapped Accessible
  • Comfortable Waiting Area
  • Children's Play Area
View all services and amenities

Why You Should Buy a New Car From Us

At Andy Mohr Toyota, we offer you a large selection of Toyota New Cars, Trucks,and SUVs ... all at affordable prices. Browse through our extensive selection of New Inven ... Read more
At Andy Mohr Toyota, we offer you a large selection of Toyota New Cars, Trucks,and SUVs ... all at affordable prices. Browse through our extensive selection of New Inventory including the Toyota Tacoma, Corolla, Camry, and other models.CHECK OUT THE ALL NEW Venza!!! If you have any questions, Please contact INTERNET SALES. We have a state of the art service dept, and we service all makes and models.

Why You Should Buy a Used Car From Us

At Andy Mohr Toyota, we offer you a large selection of Toyota Certified Used Cars, Trucks, SUV's. Other Makes and Models availiable --- all at affordable prices. Browse t ... Read more
At Andy Mohr Toyota, we offer you a large selection of Toyota Certified Used Cars, Trucks, SUV's. Other Makes and Models availiable --- all at affordable prices. Browse through our extensive selection of Used inventory including the Toyota Tacoma, Corolla, Camry, 4Runner, Highlander, Avalon, and Prius. If you have any questions, Please contact INTERNET SALES. If you don't see your next car listed, we'll get it! We have a state of the art service dept, and we service all makes and models.

Languages Spoken

  • Español

Dealer Disclaimer

Disclaimer: While every reasonable effort is made to ensure the accuracy of this data, we are not responsible or liable for any inaccuracies, errors, or omissions contain ... Read more
Disclaimer: While every reasonable effort is made to ensure the accuracy of this data, we are not responsible or liable for any inaccuracies, errors, or omissions contained on these pages. Please verify any information in question with a dealership sales representative. All vehicles are subject to prior sale. All financing and leasing is subject to credit approval. All prices exclude government fees and taxes, title, $199 documentation fee, security, and destination. Includes applicable rebate.
Your Search Clear All
All Cars
Modify Your Results
A certified pre-owned car has passed a strict inspection by the original manufacturer and is backed by an extended warranty.
Some brands group models with similar body styles together. (Ex: BMW 3 Series or Mercedes-Benz C-Class)
Trim refers to both exterior and interior options that enchance a base model. (Ex: Ford Mustang GT or Honda Accord EX)
These dealers accept offers from our Trade-In Marketplace, which determines the value of your car and provides an instant, free offer. Offers are guaranteed as long as the car's condition and information are verified.
1000,2000,3000,4000,5000,6000,7000,8000,9000,10000,11000,12000,13000,14000,15000,16000,17000,18000,19000,20000,22000,24000,26000,28000,30000,35000,40000,45000,50000,55000,60000,65000,70000,75000,80000,85000,90000,95000,100000$1,000,$2,000,$3,000,$4,000,$5,000,$6,000,$7,000,$8,000,$9,000,$10,000,$11,000,$12,000,$13,000,$14,000,$15,000,$16,000,$17,000,$18,000,$19,000,$20,000,$22,000,$24,000,$26,000,$28,000,$30,000,$35,000,$40,000,$45,000,$50,000,$55,000,$60,000,$65,000,$70,000,$75,000,$80,000,$85,000,$90,000,$95,000,$100,000

Style

Choose more »

Make

Choose more »

Exterior Color

Choose more »

Engine

Features

Choose more »

Fuel Type

Interior Color

Choose more »
Page 1 of 15 
You have already selected three cars.
Next »

Dealer Ratings

24-Month Overall Rating
  • 4.2
    Customer Service
  • 4.3
    Quality Of Work
  • 4.4
    Friendliness
  • 4.2
    Overall Experience
  • 3.9
    Price

Dealership Reviews

1 - 5 of 105 
Flodini10/09/2014 07:02:14 PM
1.8
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:No
Who Helped Me:Erik Spersrud,Kelsey Bail,Joe Pollard,Geno Kyle,Mark Meier,Rick Wright,Troy York,Scott Vallier,Max Hopper,Rick Sullivan,Collette Hawkins,Will Schooley,Russ Seals,Jim Flodder,Larry Wilcher,John Gick,Chris Franklin,Dan Mulled,Gary Gibson,Sara Strahm,Dave Fredbloom,Tommy Proffer,Jessica McDonnell,Lisa Oatts,Gary Jones,Mark Lesco,Scott Egan,Roy Weddle,Braxton Denton,Aaron Rhoades
I went to Andy Mohr dealership with my father after finding a car I liked online.. once we arrived we started working with the salesmen named David Osborn. . After test driving the car and sitting down with David , we asked about the price.. David came back with a price my father and I didn't agree with, as we were leaving the GM got our attention and asked us if we liked the car.. we told him we did and he asked us how much money we had and we told him.. he came back with another price we had to think about. So we left .. that nite me and dad spoke about the price we were given AND decided it was a good deal.. the very next morning I called Davjd and told him I wanted the car and would be in to get it around noon.. Everything was set to go.. About an hour after speaking to David I received a call from Davjd saying that the other general manager that was in didn't like the deal the day befores general manager gave us and said we couldn't get the car we wanted unless we came up with. Another 500 dollars. . I was FLABBERGASTED.. David felt my pain and said he ubderstood if he was going to lose this sale and didn't have any other options for us.. I told him my dad and I are giving you guys what you asked for and nkw that it's time to buy the car we have to cough up 500 more dollars?!?! WOW this is piss poor management and shady Shady business. . Never would I ever recommend this dealership to anyone and warn everyone that this place is a disgrace to car dealerships ...David was very apologetic but still his managers mad him and Andy Mohr Toyota In Avon in look like a huge joke! !
kelly.howell.7359/08/2014 11:02:43 AM
5.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(NEW)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Christopher Potter
Thanks to Eric Wilson and Chris Potter, I got a great deal on my 2014 Prius! Chris was professional and friendly, every step of the way. If you want a great deal, go to Andy Mohr Toyota!
pearlofprice8/25/2014 09:02:00 PM
1.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:No
Who Helped Me:Derick Clements,Mark Meier
About three years ago I purchased a CRV through Mark Meier. Loved the vehicle...hated the way it went. I came in telling them exactly what I wanted and could afford. Spend forever filling out paperwork only to find out the car was $200 more a month than I told him I could comfortably afford. I was a little more naive back then and gave in to a much higher payment than I wanted. Fast forward to two days ago. An older wiser me gets letters offering to buy back my car. I call and tell them exactly what I owe. They say they probably can't buy it outright but can definitely get me into a much lower payment if I trade in. We decide to trade in both our vehicles at once and replace them both. Youd think buying two cars would get you a little basic decency but no. Again I go in this time i am dealing with Derik who is going back and forth with Mark (should have known it would be bad). Again I tell them exactly what I want. Again they show me vehicles they say will work with what we want to do. Only they don't. Not without ending up right back where I was payment wise. I made it clear I like my car and it runs fine. I need out of the big payment. Then it is suggested I just buy a new car and "let the old one go back". I say why would I do that and take a chance on my perfectly good car going to auction and leaving a balance I would then have to pay while trying to pay for a new one. He acted suprized like he didnt know that could happen. Yeah right. Then they said they could only offer me 6500 for my trade when a car not even as nice as mine and only one year newer sat on their lot for $13k. Four hours in we were close to closing time on a Saturday. We were told he'd call back Monday morning. The call never came and he has avoided my calls. They make you sit for hour while they are supposedly working with finance companies. My guess is so you wear down and will settle for less than what you came for. When you tell them what you want and can afford they take it not as a guideline to help you get what you want but as a starting point for negotiation and purposely show you things you can't afford. Then after they waste several hours of your time they don't even have the common courtesy to take your call. If a repeat customer buying two vehicles can't get reasonable service it makes me wonder how they stay in business.
barryj986/25/2014 08:54:26 PM
1.2
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(NEW)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:No
Who Helped Me:russ
My lease was up in one week. I had a gauranteed buyout price in the original lease paperwork. I fully understood and expected to pay sales tax on top of that. They tried to charge me 2000 OVER the agreed upon price and THEN charge me sales tax on top of that. I had previously purchased 6 cars from Andy Mohr. NEVER AGAIN. All the salesman could tell me was there are FEES. 2000 in fees?? These people have become crooks.
bobbys115/07/2014 04:57:14 PM
1.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(NEW)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:No
Who Helped Me:Sales, Sales GM, Customer Advocate
My father died and I needed a car to get to Florida the next day. I called and was quoted a fair price for a lease. Walked to the dealership and was there for 6 hours. Every 15 - 20 minutes the Sales Rep came out and said we were almost there. After the 6 hours I was told we were all set. The price I was quoted for the lease was $150 per month. When I entered to do the paperwork the price was $232 per month. Keep in mind I am still grieving and they knew this and took advantage of me. So I gave them $5000 and this reduced the lease to $144 a month. When I got to Florida and finished with the funeral home I reviewed my paperwork and discovered how royally they took advantage of me (I know it was partially my fault, but keep in mind I was grieving). I figured out that the car at LIST price was around $18,250. If I purchase the car at the end of lease (which I kind of have to since I gave them the $5000 down) I will have paid $20,043 (not including taxes, etc.). TO MAKE MATTERS WORSE, WHEN I GOT HOME A WEEK LATER THERE WAS A COUPON IN MY MAIL BOX OFFERING A $3000 DISCOUNT ON THE SAME CAR. I immediately called Andy Mohr and was directed to the "Customer Advocate". This woman, who was looking out for my best interests said "WE DID HOLD A GUN TO YOUR HEAD TO BUY THE CAR". Next I approached the Sales Manager who told me too bad, I signed it, and walked away. Next I wrote a letter to Andy Mohr, and there was never a response. I called Toyota Financial and two individuals told me I was taken advantage of, but only the dealer could do anything. I next called Toyota advocacy and spoke to two individuals who told me I was severely taken advantage of. They tried for four consecutive days to get someone at Andy Mohr to help, and no one at Andy Mohr would respond to them or call me. So.....there you have it and I hope this helps someone in the future. They are the most unethical, immoral, and rotten people I have ever had to deal with. When I took the car to get my free oil change I walked the lot and two of their own sales reps (one man/one woman) told me that I got screwed. One even told me that during their training they are instructed that "buyers are liars". I can not put into words how corrupt these people are. To take advantage of someone in my situation, to repeatedly lie, to fail to show any remorse or conscience is to me the most reprehensible offense there was ever done to me. To make comments such as the "gun" comment or "if you bought a television at Best Buy and it went on sale the next day do you think they would give you the extra back?" (This was in regards to the $3000 coupon which they would not honor one week later). I'll be quiet now, but for heaven's sake, stay away from these people. They are in essence xxx.
Next »
This image is a stock photo and is not an exact representation of any vehicle offered for sale. Advertised vehicles of this model may have styling, trim levels, colors and optional equipment that differ from the stock photo.
Close 
AutoTrader.com