• Sign in
  • |
  • Sign up

Toy Barn

5100 Post RoadDublin, OH 43017
1-866-409-19521-866-409-1952

Services and Amenities

  • Handicapped Accessible
  • Comfortable Waiting Area
  • Concierge
  • Delivery Options

Why You Should Buy a Used Car From Us

Your source for luxury highline vehicles, family owned and operated. Committed to offering the highest levels of customer care. We specialize in the highest quality of hi ... Read more
Your source for luxury highline vehicles, family owned and operated. Committed to offering the highest levels of customer care. We specialize in the highest quality of highline cars avatlable. Please feel free to visit the rest of our high quality inventory at www.toybarncars.com.

Dealer Disclaimer

Sales Tax, Title, License Fee, Registration Fee, Dealer Documentary Fee, Finance Charges, Emission Testing Fees and Compliance Fees are additional to the advertised price ... Read more
Sales Tax, Title, License Fee, Registration Fee, Dealer Documentary Fee, Finance Charges, Emission Testing Fees and Compliance Fees are additional to the advertised price.
Your Search
Modify Results
A certified pre-owned car has passed a strict inspection by the original manufacturer and is backed by an extended warranty.
Some brands group models with similar body styles together. (Ex: BMW 3 Series or Mercedes-Benz C-Class)
Trim refers to both exterior and interior options that enchance a base model. (Ex: Ford Mustang GT or Honda Accord EX)
These dealers accept offers from our Trade-In Marketplace, which determines the value of your car and provides an instant, free offer. Offers are guaranteed as long as the car's condition and information are verified.
1000,2000,3000,4000,5000,6000,7000,8000,9000,10000,11000,12000,13000,14000,15000,16000,17000,18000,19000,20000,22000,24000,26000,28000,30000,35000,40000,45000,50000,55000,60000,65000,70000,75000,80000,85000,90000,95000,100000$1,000,$2,000,$3,000,$4,000,$5,000,$6,000,$7,000,$8,000,$9,000,$10,000,$11,000,$12,000,$13,000,$14,000,$15,000,$16,000,$17,000,$18,000,$19,000,$20,000,$22,000,$24,000,$26,000,$28,000,$30,000,$35,000,$40,000,$45,000,$50,000,$55,000,$60,000,$65,000,$70,000,$75,000,$80,000,$85,000,$90,000,$95,000,$100,000
Style
Choose more »
Make
Choose more »
Model
Select Bentley models »
Type
Exterior Color
Choose more »
Features
Choose more »
Interior Color
Choose more »
Page 1 of 1
Next »
Sorry, we couldn't find your dream car.
No listings found with the selected filters.

Dealer Ratings

24-Month Overall Rating
  • 4.9
    Customer Service
  • 4.9
    Quality Of Work
  • 4.9
    Friendliness
  • 4.9
    Overall Experience
  • 4.7
    Price

Dealership Reviews

1 - 5 of 160 
jenhop5/20/2015 12:10:19 PM
5.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Adrian Crabtree,Greg McDevitt
This dealership specializes in high end automobiles and limited editions. I, however, was looking for a specific used car and they happened to have a trade in Audi A5 used. It was MINT. 2009, low miles, fully loaded--clean. Price was perfect, they went above and beyond for financing and treated me the same as one of their Porsche purchasers. Greg McDevitt delivered exactly what he promised and their finance Director, Adrian Crabtree finagled financing for me with which I was exceptionally please. I live in Michigan and would absolutely make the trip again to purchase from this team. Thank you Toy Barn!! Jen
johnsonk35/20/2015 12:01:40 AM
5.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Adrian Crabtree,Frank Tillitson
Frank and The Toy Barn did a wonderful job helping me pick out a new car for my birthday/promotion. I traded in my Camry SE and purchased a Lexus RC 350 they had on the lot. Not only did they give me a generous trade-in value on my Camry, but they also worked with me in the final sale price of the Lexus and the financing. They were extremely flexible with my schedule and were more than accommodating. I'm extremely happy I ended up choosing The Toy Barn. I will definitely be back to do business with Frank and The Toy Barn! Thanks again guys!
shark675/15/2015 07:16:02 PM
4.8
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Frank Tillitson
purchased a 99 bmw z3m. buying experience was excellent. you get the feeling these are real car guys here and they want you to be happy with the deal. car was better than advertised.
Evo_mirage225/15/2015 06:07:48 PM
5.0
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SALES(USED)
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Justin Hinderer,Adrian Crabtree,Frank Tillitson
I purchased my 2006 Lancer evolution se moving up on 4 months ago from the toy barn. I saw the car one night when driving through the lot and knew I had to buy it! I had been searching for the past few years for an evo but none really stood out as my car to me. I called the very next morning asking to look it over and talk numbers. I then met up with Frank later that day; and this is one of the things that shocked me most was that he saw a 21 year old kid trying to buy a sports car and didn't treat me any different than he would treat some old rich guy. I had been to a mitsubishi dealership at a separate occasion and the manager acted like he wanted nothing to do with me. Later that week I finally closed on the car with Justin and frank, with them both working some magic to help me get it. I really appreciate everything they did and I would recommend all of my friends and family here! Thanks again for all the help Justin and frank! Hope to buy more from you in the future!
dpl5/15/2015 01:59:03 PM
4.4
Overall Rating
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Overall Experience
Price
Reason for My Visit:SERVICE
Would I Recommend this Dealer:Yes
Who Helped Me:Kyle Eubanks
I wanted to figure out whether or not it made sense to sink some money into my '96 300ZX with the intent to keep it for another 3-5 years, or accept the inevitable and part ways. After considering a number of other service options, I found the Toy Barn the only place that really understood what I wanted. They did a terrific job of getting the car back to the ride and look it had when it was new. I'd have given them 5 stars except I had a hard time getting updates. It legitimately took some time to get the job done, but when there were days when something was expected or promised, I had to call. If they were on top of the in-process communications, it would be a slam dunk top rating. In spite of that nuisance aspect, I'd go back in a minute for anything similar. They did an awesome job and it was clear they cared about doing it right and satisfying me. I should add that if you're looking only at their hourly rate for service you can easily find cheaper, but I feel I got a very good value. I spent a fair amount, but I feel I got a lot. I gave the deal a 'fair' rating, as that is exactly what it was.
Next »
This image is a stock photo and is not an exact representation of any vehicle offered for sale. Advertised vehicles of this model may have styling, trim levels, colors and optional equipment that differ from the stock photo.
Close 
Autotrader