What if Santa couldn't find his sleigh? And OK, what if he also developed a sudden fear of flying? Staying home isn't really an option, at least not this time of year. So how would our favorite red-pajama-clad geriatric deliver the goods? 

Naturally, he'd have to drive, which would briefly make him the world's most important car shopper -- because it's not like he already has one in the garage. But what car? If Mr. Claus could only pick one new ride, what would it be? Just in case he happens to be on the horns of this dilemma (and frantically searching the Internet for a solution), we put our heads together and came up with five sensible sets of wheels for his consideration. 

Jeep Wrangler Unlimited

Pros: Go-anywhere capability; removable roof and long wheelbase afford sleigh-like cargo capacity

Cons: Unpleasant on long trips (and this will be a long one indeed) 

Think first about how Santa's going to get out of the North Pole. No magic, remember, and no airplanes or helicopters, either. An excellent snow vehicle would make this leg a lot easier, and we can't think of a better choice than the off-road-ready Wrangler Unlimited. It comes straight from the factory with the hardware to dominate any terrain, and with the 3.6-liter Pentastar V6 aboard, it can actually make some time on smoother surfaces, too -- albeit with more than its fair share of wind and road noise. Why the long-wheelbase Unlimited? Hey, have you seen how big that sack of presents is? 

Find a Jeep Wrangler for sale

Toyota Sienna

Pros: Room for tons of presents and a bunch of elves; dual-view entertainment system keeps the little helpers happy

Cons: Requires paved roads; driving an uncool minivan could tarnish Santa's image

The Sienna is obviously an on-road vehicle only, but assuming Mr. Claus could make it out of the Arctic Circle in a minivan (maybe the reindeer could tow him), there's plenty of pavement in the rest of the world. To the Toyota's credit, it offers all-wheel drive, so slippery winter streets wouldn't be a problem. And for gift-sack capacity in passenger vehicles, you just can't beat a minivan. Throw in the Sienna's 16.4-inch rear entertainment screen with dual-view capability -- bored elves are mischief-prone, as you may expect -- and you have some strong sleigh-replacement credentials.

Find a Toyota Sienna for sale

Chevrolet Corvette Stingray Coupe

Pros: Speedy gift delivery; fun; the kids would definitely approve

Cons: Support vehicle for gift sack required

With all the automotive toys Mr. Claus has delivered over the years, as well as the actual vehicles for those of driving age, he has to be something of a car guy by now. And the car to have this holiday season is definitely the brand-new C7 Corvette. It's not just about the 455-horsepower V8, either; the Corvette is also known as the big man's sports car due to its generous seat travel and passenger space, so his famous gut should fit without issue. One major downside is that there's only room for a few presents at a time, but maybe the Clauses could get a Suburban support vehicle thrown in for cheap. A team of elves could probably figure out how to drive an enormous SUV, right? 

Find a Chevy Corvette for sale

Volkswagen Touareg TDI

Pros: At home on any surface; handy cargo hold with the rear seats folded; great range and fuel economy

Cons: Firm ride could pose a threat to fragile presents 

For one vehicle that does it all, it's hard to beat the diesel-powered Touareg TDI. It shares its platform with the Porsche Cayenne, so you know the dynamics and general robustness are beyond reproach. It has ample ride height and suspension travel for off-roading, yet it's a high-speed champ on the freeway. Its massive 406 lb-ft of torque piles on around 2,000 rpm, making it a great choice for hauling, say, a really heavy red bag. And on those long rural stretches without many filling stations, the Touareg's 29-miles-per-gallon highway rating and 750-mile driving range would keep Santa's anxiety at bay. Shame the optional air suspension is no longer available, though; the Touareg's stiff-legged suspension might break a Christmas vase or two. 

Find a VW Touareg for sale

RAM 1500 EcoDiesel V6

Pros: Open-air cargo area; coil springs yield soft ride; diesel maximizes mpg

Cons: Oversized dimensions are cumbersome on tight city streets 

At the end of the day, maybe Santa should just get a truck. There's a reason big trucks are so popular among Americans: You just can't beat the combined utility of a cargo bed and industrial-grade hauling capacity. And the new-for-2014 RAM 1500 EcoDiesel is the only half-ton truck with diesel power, so he would enjoy a peerless combination of torque (420 lb-ft) and mileage per gallon (projected to be in the high 20s). Also, the RAM's uniquely smooth coil-spring suspension would do the Touareg one better, giving breakable items a fighting chance of getting under the tree intact. The big fella would have his work cut out in older cities and towns, however, as the beefy RAM doesn't play nice with narrow, winding roads. 

Find a RAM 1500 for sale

AutoTrader Says

Whichever one you choose, Santa, don't forget to live-tweet this year's trip. It'll be great publicity for the automaker. If you play your cards right, you may even get the vehicle for free.

author photo

Josh Sadlier is an automotive journalist based in Los Angeles and has contributed to such publications as Edmunds.com and DriverSide.com. He holds arguably the most unexpected degree in his profession: a master's in Theological Studies.

Related Articles & Car Reviews

Find Cars for sale near you:

Research by Vehicle Type

  • Convertible
  • Coupe
  • Hatchback
  • Hybrid
  • Luxury
  • Sedan
  • SUV
  • Truck
  • Van/Minivan
  • Wagon

Shopping Tools

Compare the 2014 Chevrolet Corvette with these competing Coupes:

  • 2014 Honda Civic Coupe
  • 2014 Maserati GranTurismo
  • 2014 SRT SRT Viper

For Sale on Autotrader.com

Please enter your ZIP to see prices and listings near you.

Loading Ajax Content Loading Ajax Content