Search Cars for Sale

Should You Walk Away from a Used Car Extended Warranty?

If you’re interested in buying a used car, you might be thinking about getting an extended warranty to go along with it. After all, a used car could be troublesome or expensive, and an extended warranty may be a good way to avoid risk.

Should you buy an extended warranty? We explain a few situations when it might be a good idea and a few more when you should walk away.

Should You Purchase an Extended Warranty?

In general, we don’t recommend buying an extended warranty on a used car.

Warranty companies are in business to make money, and they’ve usually done their homework. This means you’ll likely spend more on the extended warranty — $3,000 or more, in some cases — than any repair costs your car may accrue during the period when the warranty stays valid. Additionally, many people who purchase extended warranties never use them.

There are, however, some exceptions.

RELATED STORIES: Certified Pre-Owned: Why Not Just Buy an Extended Warranty Instead?

When to Consider a Used Car Extended Warranty

When weighing an extended warranty, you’ll want to know about the exceptions and the times you may need one. For example, if the used car make and model is notoriously unreliable.

You can check the vehicle’s performance by researching car reliability ratings and checking out reviews, including on Autotrader. You can also get some opinions from knowledgeable mechanics and other drivers who have owned the same car.

If the car you want doesn’t have the best reliability record, check out the two cases when you might want to consider an extended warranty.

  • It’s an exclusion warranty: Does the warranty cover everything except for items that it specifically excludes? That usually allows for a more comprehensive warranty and a lower chance for a claim to be denied. Of note, typical wear and tear items will be excluded.
  • The extended warranty cost seems reasonable. A warranty’s cost shouldn’t be cost-prohibitive. You don’t want to spend too much money to protect yourself against problems that may never come up. If it’s reasonably priced, consider what it will cover and weigh that against what costs you may face for any potential repairs.

Find a used car for sale near you

When to Walk Away From an Extended Warranty

There are several circumstances in which you should walk away from an extended warranty on a used vehicle.

  • The used vehicle is still under a manufacturer’s warranty. If the manufacturer’s warranty still covers the car, we strongly caution against buying an extended warranty. You have no idea if you’ll own the car when the factory warranty expires. So, you’ll have ample opportunity to buy an extended warranty as the factory warranty’s expiration date draws nearer. Some manufacturer warranties like Hyundai cover the repair or replacement of the vehicle’s powertrain for 10 years or 100,000 miles. That includes select engine and transmission components. However, that coverage applies only to the original owner starting with Hyundai model year 2004 and newer vehicles.
  • The car gets good reviews. You should avoid a warranty if your car gets great scores for reliability. Once again, check reviews or ask knowledgeable mechanics and other drivers to find out what your car’s reliability record is like. There’s no point in spending money on an extended warranty when your car probably won’t have any issues.
  • When it’s an inclusion warranty. We also suggest walking away from most inclusion warranties, which only cover specific parts. These warranties aren’t very comprehensive, especially in comparison to exclusion warranties covering all parts with some exceptions. Read the policy very carefully to find out exactly which warranty you’ll be getting.

Another major point to consider when you buy an extended warranty is to check the reputation of the company selling it. Some warranty companies have strong reputations and a nationwide presence. Unknown companies might not back up the warranty if your car begins having serious problems. We suggest spending some time researching warranty companies to find one that you’ll feel comfortable with if you plan on buying an extended warranty.

Related Used Car Stories:

Editor’s Note: This article has been updated for accuracy since it was originally published.

Doug Demuro
Doug DeMuro writes articles and makes videos, mainly about cars. Doug was born in Denver, Colorado, and received an economics degree from Emory University in Atlanta. After graduation, Doug spent three years working for Porsche Cars North America. Eventually, he quit his job to become a writer, largely because it meant that he no longer had to wear pants. Doug’s work has been featured in a... Read More about Doug Demuro

Sign up for Autotrader newsletters

The best cars and best deals delivered to your inbox

Email Address 

By subscribing, you agree to our privacy policy

Where You Can Buy

Loading dealers...

39 COMMENTS

  1. Considering an extended warranty for 2014 BMW 750 I

    Vehicle has 28,000 miles,
    I’ve looked online, spoken to two different companies, both asking asking $4000 for a 5yr/60,000
    Never owned a BMW before but love the way this car drives!
    They’re asking 29,000 for the vehicle
    Can anyone please advise what other on the Beamer or as purchase an extended warranty? Thank you
  2. Bought an extended warranty a few years ago, within a week a modulator of some type went, of course no electronics were covered,cost me $400. A mechanic friend once told me,”extended warranties cover about 500 parts on a vehicle,but there are about five thousand parts on the vehicle”.

  3. To me, the extended warranty I purchased on the used vehicle I bought was nothing but a big waste of my hard earned money!  I have been having issues and those issues have not been fixed.  Now, the dealership I bought the warranty through is refusing to honor the warranty that I bought!  When I called the warranty company they were zero help, which left me more frustrated than before!  So now I am stuck paying for repairs out of my pocket that I can not afford.  Next time I will save the money I was going to spend on the warranty!  It has been nothing but a nightmare for me!

  4. I got an extended warranty when I bought my 2002 Monte Carlo. This was several years ago. I got the extended warranty, because it was past mfg warranty. I did use it once when the Intake was leaking oil into the cooling system. I had a $200 deductible. The bill was $700, so they covered $500. The extended warranty was $3000, and added into the price of the car when I financed it. I don’t do extended warranties anymore. I got them on other cars before, and never had to use them. Save your money. 

Leave a Comment

Most Popular Articles

2020 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid: First Look

The 2020 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid jumps to the head of the hybrid class.

Best Truck Deals: October 2021

These are the best deals on trucks for the month of October 2021.

Search By Style

More Articles Like This