Home Car Shopping How Many Owners Is Too Many for a Used Car?

How Many Owners Is Too Many for a Used Car?

Quick Facts About Used Cars With Multiple Owners

If you’re interested in buying a used car, you probably want a one-owner vehicle. Nearly everyone does. But not everyone is lucky enough to find one, especially if the car you desire is more than a few years old.

We are not talking about vintage cars or old beaters here. We’re talking about buying a solid used vehicle to drive around town with your family and friends.

Some background: A few years ago, supply chain disruptions reduced the number of new vehicles on dealer lots, so would-be new car buyers started looking for used vehicles. That supply and demand situation reduced stock and increased prices for used models. Today, some dealers are sitting on an oversupply of new cars while the industry tries to return to “normal.” Used inventory will increase as consumers trade their older vehicles for new models, raising the possibility of finding a car with more than one previous owner.

Is that OK, and is it bad to choose a vehicle with multiple previous owners? How can you tell how many people have owned a car? We give you the answers and tell you what’s more important.

Should the Car Only Have One Owner?

There are several reasons why one-owner cars are considered the darlings of the used car world. This is why:

  1. Level of care. If someone buys a new car and drives it for a decade, the car likely received roughly the same level of care — and the same driving experience — throughout that time. With multiple owners, a car is subjected to various levels of care and a wide range of driving styles, which could negatively affect its long-term dependability.
  2. Knowledge of vehicle history. Another reason one-owner cars are so sought-after is that the original owner, who purchased the car new, likely devoted fewer financial resources to maintenance and upkeep than, say, a sixth owner who buys the car when it’s 15 years old and costs $4,000. In other words, one owner probably knows the vehicle’s history better than if several drivers owned the car.

However, looking for a used vehicle with just one owner can be challenging in this market. While the number of used cars for sale increases, prices remain high, and the supply is still lean. That situation leaves some buyers to jump when a vehicle in their price range becomes available — even if it’s had a half-dozen owners. That is, as long as the car is mechanically sound. 

Do your due diligence, including finding out the vehicle’s value, no matter how many past owners drove that automobile. Read on to find out how.

How to Research a Car’s Ownership History

Mechanic Working on Engine

You should look at the vehicle history report when buying a used car. Services like AutoCheck and Carfax provide essential information that helps you understand the vehicle’s ownership. Most service centers will submit maintenance information to history report providers, though it is not required. Official activity, such as title changes, registration, and accidents reported to insurance carriers, will show up. An oil change from a neighborhood mechanic might not appear on the full report.

Some Key Items You Can Expect to Find

  1. How many owners
  2. Ownership location
  3. If the car was leased or owned
  4. Length of ownership
  5. Estimated car miles driven per year
  6. Title history
  7. How many reported accidents
  8. Maintenance history

Reports cost less than $40 for that peace of mind. If buying a used car at a dealership, they usually provide the report free of charge, as do people using Autotrader’s Private Seller Exchange. It’s important not to overlook the finer details in these reports, like if you notice any holes. Be aware that some incidents might not be reported to these sites, so don’t hesitate to ask for maintenance records.

TIP: Research the vehicle’s recalls to determine if it has any excessive defects. You can check for vehicle recalls using our sister site, Kelley Blue Book.

Be sure to check out Certified Pre-Owned models when shopping at dealerships. Many carmakers now offer higher mileage programs for certified pre-owned vehicles, providing better safeguards and assurances for car shoppers.

Before buying, always trust your instincts, ask a qualified mechanic to inspect the vehicle, and take the car on a thorough test drive to listen for unexpected sounds, sniff for unusual odors, and look for excessive wear and tear. Be confident before signing any paperwork because, in most cases, you cannot return a car once you buy it.

Is More Than One Car Owner Too Many?

And now on to the all-important question of what to do. We prefer cars with fewer owners, as they will likely be better maintained and preserved. However, you should not rule out a multiple-owner used car with a clean history that received regular maintenance; you should consider the vehicle. While the number of owners should be a factor when buying a used car, it shouldn’t be the only consideration. We believe a vehicle’s mechanical condition should be far more critical than its ownership history.

Editor’s Note: This article has been updated since its initial publication.

Sign up for Autotrader newsletters

The best cars and best deals delivered to your inbox

Where You Can Buy

Loading dealers...