Autotrader Logo
Skip to vehicle Listings
Your next car is just a chat away. Try AI Mode

Used Toyota Cars for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

11706
Filters (2)
Items 1 to 2 of 20.
    Sponsored by Atlantic Toyota
    Hide
    Used 2025 Toyota 4Runner TRD Off-Road
    51,906
    See estimated payment
    Atlantic Toyota
    (934) 348-4135
    Call
    Dealer Logo
    71View Vehicles

    807 Matches

    Used 2021 Toyota RAV4 XLE
    Used

    2021 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE
    • 39K mi
    Hybrid
    30,989
    No Accidents
    Sponsored by Nissan of Westbury
    • 15.78 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2023 Toyota Tacoma TRD Sport w/ Advanced Technology Package
    Used

    2023 Toyota Tacoma

    • TRD Sport
    • 48K mi
    38,980
    No Accidents
    Sponsored by Atlantic Toyota
    • 2.72 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2022 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 29K mi
    35,995
    Dealer Fees Included
    Sponsored by Empire Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram of West Islip
    • 1.93 mi. away
    Call
    My Wallet

    Find it Fast.

    Keep it Affordable.

    Credit Rating
    Trade-In Value
    Get My Kelley Blue Book® CarValue
    Get My Payoff Quote

    $

    Based on 4.5% APR for mos.
    Used 2006 Toyota Prius
    Used

    2006 Toyota Prius

    • 175K mi
    Hybrid
    3,300
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 2.91 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Used 2008 Toyota Land Cruiser
    Used

    2008 Toyota Land Cruiser

    • 7K mi
    70,000
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 2.49 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Newly Listed
    Used 2019 Toyota Highlander Limited Platinum
    Used

    2019 Toyota Highlander

    • Limited Platinum
    • 98K mi
    26,000
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 9.91 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Advertisement
    Used 2017 Toyota Tundra SR5 w/ SR5 Upgrade Package
    Used

    2017 Toyota Tundra

    • SR5
    • 24K mi
    35,500
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 10.64 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Price Drop
    Used 2012 Toyota 4Runner SR5 w/ Convenience Pkg
    Used

    2012 Toyota 4Runner

    • SR5
    • 152K mi
    16,800
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 11.26 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Used 2009 Toyota Camry XLE
    Used

    2009 Toyota Camry

    • XLE
    • 124K mi
    7,999
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 4.42 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Used 2008 Toyota Corolla CE
    Used

    2008 Toyota Corolla

    • CE
    • 42K mi
    9,500
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 11.77 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Used 2025 Toyota Highlander XSE
    Used

    2025 Toyota Highlander

    • XSE
    • 11K mi
    47,638
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Hertz Car Sales Smithtown
    • Buy Online
    Call
    Advertisement
    Used 2025 Toyota RAV4 XSE w/ Advanced Technology Package
    Used

    2025 Toyota RAV4

    • XSE
    • 3K mi
    Hybrid
    42,320
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 8.26 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Price Drop
    360°
    Used 2025 Toyota Corolla SE w/ SE Premium Package
    Used

    2025 Toyota Corolla

    • SE
    • 2K mi
    23,412
    No Accidents
    Empire Toyota of Huntington
    • 8.61 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2009 Toyota Venza AWD
    Used

    2009 Toyota Venza

    • AWD
    • 57K mi
    10,998
    Dealer Fees Included
    New Country Lexus of Great Neck
    • 24.52 mi. away
    • Online Paperwork
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2022 Toyota RAV4 XSE
    Used

    2022 Toyota RAV4

    • XSE
    • 25K mi
    Hybrid
    36,498
    Dealer Fees Included
    New Country Lexus of Great Neck
    • 24.52 mi. away
    • Online Paperwork
    Call
    Advertisement
    Price Drop
    Used 2025 Toyota RAV4 LE
    Used

    2025 Toyota RAV4

    • LE
    • 5K mi
    31,445
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Advantage Honda
    • 9.73 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2022 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 29K mi
    35,995
    Dealer Fees Included
    Empire Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram of West Islip
    • 1.93 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2008 Toyota Prius
    Used

    2008 Toyota Prius

    • 171K mi
    Hybrid
    6,000
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 9.69 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Price Drop
    Used 2024 Toyota RAV4 XSE w/ Premium Package
    Used

    2024 Toyota RAV4

    • XSE
    • 16K mi
    Hybrid
    43,472
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Competition BMW of Smithtown
    • 9.8 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2021 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 49K mi
    32,298
    No Accidents
    Bright Bay Lincoln
    • 0.75 mi. away
    Call
    360°
    Used 2018 Toyota RAV4 XLE w/ Plus Extra Value Package
    Used

    2018 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE
    • 42K mi
    21,920
    No Accidents
    Honda City
    • 11.35 mi. away
    Call
    360°
    Used 2020 Toyota RAV4 XLE Premium
    Used

    2020 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE Premium
    • 49K mi
    26,875
    Honda City
    • 11.35 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2025 Toyota Highlander XSE
    Used

    2025 Toyota Highlander

    • XSE
    • 28K mi
    42,995
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Hertz Rent2Buy Smithtown, NY
    • Buy Online
    Call
    Used 2024 Toyota Tundra Limited w/ TRD Off-Road Package
    Used

    2024 Toyota Tundra

    • Limited
    • 17K mi
    Hybrid
    49,998
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    New Country Lexus of Great Neck
    • 24.52 mi. away
    • Online Paperwork
    Call
    Used 2024 Toyota Highlander LE
    Used

    2024 Toyota Highlander

    • LE
    • 15K mi
    37,825
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    The New Babylon Honda
    • 5.93 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2023 Toyota Highlander XSE
    Used

    2023 Toyota Highlander

    • XSE
    • 25K mi
    42,995
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    The New Babylon Honda
    • 5.93 mi. away
    Call
    Newly Listed
    360°
    Used 2023 Toyota Tundra 1794 Edition
    Used

    2023 Toyota Tundra

    • 1794 Edition
    • 17K mi
    53,998
    No Accidents
    Millennium Toyota
    • 19.43 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2019 Toyota Camry LE
    Used

    2019 Toyota Camry

    • LE
    • 99K mi
    18,500
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 13.77 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Advertisement

    Used Toyota for Sale by Model

    View All Models
    <!--{"relevance":[false,{}]}-->