Search Cars for Sale

Buying a Car: How Much Do You Really Save By Buying Used?

If you’re interested in buying a car, you’ve probably realized that you can save a little money — and sometimes more than just a little — by buying a used model. But what kind of discount should you expect by choosing a used model instead of a new one? And more importantly, do you actually end up saving any money in the long run? We’re taking a quick look to help you figure it out.

New vs. Used: The Savings

There’s no question that you’ll save money up front when you buy a used car over a new one. For proof, just take a look at lightly used 2013 models on Autotrader compared to their brand-new 2015 counterparts. Drivers can usually save a lot of money by simply going back a couple model years and picking up a used version of the car they want, rather than opting for a brand new one off a dealer’s lot.

But just how much can you save? It depends on a lot of factors — like mileage, age and desirability. A 2-year-old Subaru Outback may offer more savings than a 2-year-old Honda Accord, for instance — but that’s because the Outback has just been redesigned, unlike the Accord. To many buyers, that means a 2-year-old Outback uses the previous model’s styling and technology, while the Accord is still fairly fresh. Meanwhile, a 2-year-old Accord with 40,000 miles will offer much more savings than one with 5,000 miles.

Still, you can usually expect to save at least a few thousand dollars off the price of a brand-new model by picking a used version. And, of course, you should expect to save even more if you’re willing to consider older models with even higher miles.

The Drawbacks

But picking up a used car isn’t all about saving money up front. Yes, it’s true, you’ll get a good deal off a new model — but at what cost? If you choose a car that’s 2 or 3 years old, the primary drawback is warranty coverage: you might be at the end of a car’s bumper-to-bumper coverage and rapidly approaching the end of its powertrain warranty, too. That means you’ll have to pay out of pocket for parts that break, while a new car buyer wouldn’t have to think about those items for a while.

But warranty coverage isn’t the only drawback. A car that’s 2 or 3 years old will also have 2- or 3-year-old tires and brakes, which means you’ll be that much closer to replacing them. And new cars are often available with far better interest rates than their used counterparts — even if the used models are just a year or two old — which can work out to additional expenses in the long run.

Do You Save Money in the End?

So do you actually save money by buying a used car? Our answer is a resounding “maybe,” depending on the vehicle, the age of the used car in question, and exactly what you’re paying.

In general, though, we think you can save money by buying a car that’s 1 or 2 years old, compared to a brand-new model — but we understand that many shoppers would rather pay the premium for a new car than take the gamble on a used model. Given the potential drawbacks we’ve listed above, that makes sense to us, too.

Doug Demuro
Doug DeMuro writes articles and makes videos, mainly about cars. Doug was born in Denver, Colorado, and received an economics degree from Emory University in Atlanta. After graduation, Doug spent three years working for Porsche Cars North America. Eventually, he quit his job to become a writer, largely because it meant that he no longer had to wear pants. Doug’s work has been featured in a... Read More

Sign up for Autotrader newsletters

The best cars and best deals delivered to your inbox

Email Address 

By subscribing, you agree to our privacy policy

Where You Can Buy

Loading dealers...

3 COMMENTS

  1. I bought a brand new car and it worked fine until the warranty expired. The 100,000 mile warranty expired after 5 years then I was changing one sensor after another. The wiper blade bracket rusted out. I got rid of it and bought a used car. I paid cash for it and other than regular maintenance the car has been great. I am saving a ton of money since i do the oil changes, brakes and transmission fluid changes myself. I will never buy new again.

  2. The sweet spot for bargains that are potentially great cars are 5-10 years old,  under 100k miles,  verifiable maintenance and ownership history,  and no accidents.  Stick with models that were highly rated to begin with and still are.  You can find these at 25%-40% of their original cost and there’s really nothing wrong with them (you have to verify that of course—AAA for instance has a buyer inspection service).
    The dealers are set to exploit you to the maximum.  Stay away from them.

  3. IF buyers do research at NADA, KBB and other sites…and know how to sell their current cars online through places like Craigslist (have done several times)…they can save HUGE $$$.  Example, I bought a high end convertible that listed for $65k…it was 1.5 years old, still has substantial warranty months and mileage…for $25K less than list…and $8-10K less than local dealers.
    I sold my higher end sedan online for $2K more than trade in value.
    Folks…learn how to use the internet to your advantage.  Don’t limit your purchase interests to 50-150 miles…look for where the auctions are held!
    Be smart, research, save $$$$

Leave a Comment

[tdb_cox_auto_search_form f_input_font_family=”521″ f_placeholder_font_family=”521″ f_btn_font_family=”521″ f_msg_font_family=”521″ btn_tdicon=”tdc-font-fa tdc-font-fa-search” btn_icon_size=”16″ btn_icon_color=”#f76100″ btn_bg=”rgba(255,255,255,0)” input_placeholder=”Search Articles” btn_icon_pos=”after” btn_icon_space=”5″ btn_text_color=”#f76100″]

Most Popular Articles

2020 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid: First Look

The 2020 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid jumps to the head of the hybrid class.

Best Truck Deals: July 2021

These are the best deals on trucks for the month of June.

Search By Style

More Articles Like This